October 4, 2021 | Susan Napier-Sewell

Crew Ignores Inbound Warning, Departs While Control Tower is Closed

control tower

South African investigators have disclosed that a CemAir Bombardier CRJ200 crew departed from George airport before the control tower opened, despite being aware of an inbound Airlink Embraer ERJ-135 on approach to the same runway from the opposite direction.

Preliminary inquiries into the August 23, 2021, incident – classified as serious by the South African Civil Aviation Authority – have found that the airport’s control tower and approach control centers opened at different times, 15 minutes apart.

“The rational as to why the two stations opened at different times could not be determined with certainty but posed a serious safety implication on the operations at the aerodrome,” the inquiry states, pointing out that the outbound CemAir service to Johannesburg and the inbound Airlink flight from Cape Town were scheduled to be operating at George around the same time.

According to the South African inquiry, the departing CRJ200 crew was “well aware” of NOTAM information listing the differing control tower and approach opening times.

control tower
Source: South African CAA/GoogleEarth
Aircraft tracks showing how the ERJ-135 was moved from its approach path as the CRJ200 took off

As the CRJ200 taxied for runway 29, its crew was called by approach control and informed that the tower frequency would be opening within 2min and that there was an aircraft inbound for the opposite-direction runway 11 within the next seven minutes.

Despite being instructed to hold position, the CRJ’s captain replied that the flight was ready for an immediate departure and would follow the unmanned procedure to take off from runway 29 and turn left over the sea. The captain broadcast an advisory on this departure over the approach frequency.

“[The CemAir crew] did not wait for the control tower to open even after they were informed by approach control of the situation with [the Airlink flight],” says the South African inquiry.

After learning that the CemAir aircraft was rolling for take-off – about the same time as the tower opened – approach controllers told the Airlink flight to stop its descent at 8,000 feet and turned the aircraft to the south, off its approach path, instructing it to descend while the CemAir jet climbed away. The Airlink crew was then cleared to realign for a visual approach to runway 11.

Investigators have yet to reach formal conclusions on the incident. None of the 41 occupants on board the CRJ200 or the 31 on the ERJ-135 was injured.

Source: Flight Global, “CRJ200 carried out closed-tower take-off despite warning of opposite inbound flight,” September 21, 2021.

The TapRooT® Equifactor® Equipment Troubleshooting investigation process saves you time, steps, money, and frustration, and allows you to resolve the issue(s) with finality.

It is estimated that about 90% of equipment failures have a human error root cause. We can help you eliminate or mitigate your problems.

Contact us for more information. Visit our website to learn more about TapRooT® and register for a TapRooT® course.

Sharpen your equipment troubleshooting skills.

Read about Equifactor® and learn about Equifactor® Troubleshooting. Register your team for an Equifactor® course today — or contact us to discuss training your employees on-site. 

Categories
Accidents, Human Performance
Show Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *